← All Investigations
The 1890 House Museum, Cortland, New York — a meticulously preserved Victorian-era mansion built by industrialist Chester Wickwire, now operating as a historic house museum and one of the region's most notable examples of late 19th-century architecture.
October 14, 2026
Inconclusive — Pre-Investigation. This episode establishes the historical and anecdotal foundation for the location. While the consistency of reported experiences and the specific nature of some accounts are noteworthy, no formal investigation has been conducted yet. Jason approaches the location with healthy skepticism and reserves judgment until the full investigation is complete.

Inside the 1890 House Museum: Haunted History, the Wickwire Legacy, and What We Found in Cortland, NY

26.3K views on YouTube

“Chester Wickwire died inside this house — and when multiple people, without comparing notes, describe the same experiences in the same rooms, that's not something I dismiss. That's something I investigate.”

— Jason Hawes
The Investigation

Some locations stop you in your tracks before you even walk through the door. The 1890 House Museum in Cortland, New York is one of those places — a stunning Victorian-era mansion with a rich history, a prominent family name attached to it, and stories of unexplained activity that have followed it for years. JV and I went in with our usual approach: eyes open, assumptions checked at the door, and a commitment to finding the truth before jumping to any paranormal conclusions.

Findings

Before we ever set up a single piece of equipment, we do our homework. That's always been the TAPS methodology — understand the history of a location first, because nine times out of ten, history gives you a framework for what people are experiencing and why. The 1890 House was built by Chester Wickwire, a man of significant influence in the Cortland area. The Wickwire family was prominent, successful, and deeply tied to the community. The house itself reflects that — it's an architectural showpiece, a Victorian gem that speaks to ambition and craftsmanship. Walking through it, you can feel the weight of everything that happened within those walls. And yes, that includes Chester Wickwire's death. He died in this house. That detail matters. Not because it automatically makes a location haunted — it doesn't — but because it shapes the emotional narrative that people bring to a place. When you know someone died somewhere, your perception of that space shifts. Part of my job is accounting for that psychological layer before I start drawing conclusions.

JV and I sat down with the people who know this building best — the staff and historians connected to the museum — and what came out of that conversation was genuinely compelling. The reported experiences here range from subtle unease to more direct encounters: sounds that don't have an obvious source, feelings of being watched, and objects that seem to behave in ways that are hard to explain away immediately. I've heard variations of these reports at dozens of locations, and my first instinct is always to look for the mundane explanation. Old houses breathe. They settle. They have drafts, creaking floors, and acoustics that can make a whisper sound like it's coming from the next room. The 1890 House, being over 130 years old, has all of that in abundance. Before anything else gets labeled paranormal, we have to rule all of that out.

What makes this location particularly interesting from an investigative standpoint is the specificity of some of the reports. It's not just vague feelings — there are accounts tied to particular rooms and particular times. That kind of consistency is worth paying attention to. When multiple people, without coordination, describe similar experiences in the same part of a building, that's a data point. It doesn't confirm a haunting, but it tells you where to focus your attention. The connection to Chester Wickwire himself keeps surfacing in these accounts, which adds another layer to explore. Did something of him remain in this house after his death? That's the question we're here to answer — and we won't answer it by guessing. We'll answer it by investigating.

This video is the before — the history, the interviews, the groundwork. We're pulling back the curtain on what this location is, what the Wickwire family left behind, and what the people who work here have witnessed. The full investigation is coming, and when we go in, we're going in with everything we have. I've said it a thousand times: I want to find the rational explanation. I want to debunk it. That's not because I don't believe in the paranormal — my years of experience have shown me things I can't explain — but because if something genuinely defies explanation after every other option has been exhausted, that means something. The 1890 House has earned a thorough investigation, and that's exactly what it's going to get.

Verdict

Whether the 1890 House turns out to be a product of history, atmosphere, and human imagination — or something that pushes past those boundaries — the story here is worth telling. The Wickwire legacy is fascinating on its own, and the reported activity gives us plenty to work with. Stay tuned for the full investigation, and as always, watch the evidence, think critically, and decide for yourself.

TagsGhostGhost huntersParanormalJason hawesGrant WilsonSam and ColbySatoriSatori hawesCody and satoriDebunkedTapsHauntHauntingHauntedSam & ColbySam golbachColby BrockConjuringConjuring houseThe conjuringSatori and CodyEd WarrenLorraine WarrenScaryTrendingGhost AdventuresZak Bagans
More Investigations
Subscribe for new case files every week.
Subscribe on YouTube