Investigating the 1890 House Museum: What We Found Inside Cortland's Most Historic Mansion After Dark
“If you aren't actively trying to disprove what you're investigating, you're not really investigating — you're just collecting experiences and calling them evidence. The 1890 House gave us both plenty of opportunity to do the real work, and what remained after we did is what I'm still thinking about.”
— Jason Hawes
Some buildings carry their history quietly — you can feel it in the architecture, in the preserved rooms, in the weight of everything that happened between those walls. The 1890 House Museum in Cortland, New York is exactly that kind of place. Jim and I went in with our equipment, our experience, and our skepticism fully intact, determined to find out whether what people have been reporting here has a rational explanation — or something we can't as easily account for.
The 1890 House is a Gilded Age stone mansion built for industrialist Chester F. Wickwire and his family, and it has been standing in Cortland for well over 130 years. That kind of history commands respect before you ever start thinking about the paranormal. When Jim and I arrived, we took our time walking the property, learning the layout, and speaking with the people who know this building best. That part of the process matters enormously to me. Before I pull out a single piece of equipment, I want to understand what I'm walking into — the history, the architecture, the people who lived and worked there. The more you know about a location, the better equipped you are to identify what's environmental, what's psychological, and what genuinely warrants a closer look.
The mansion itself is remarkable. Elaborate interiors, preserved period details, and the kind of craftsmanship you simply don't see in modern construction. Buildings like this develop their own personalities over generations — settling foundations, aging mechanical systems, temperature fluctuations between thick stone walls and interior spaces, and acoustics that can carry sound in genuinely surprising ways. I always go into a location like this expecting to find natural explanations for the majority of what gets reported, and that expectation is not cynicism. It's methodology. If you aren't actively trying to disprove what you're investigating, you're not really investigating — you're just collecting experiences and calling them evidence.
Once Jim and I returned after dark to begin the formal investigation, we moved through the mansion methodically, covering the main rooms and paying particular attention to areas where activity had been reported. We used a combination of our standard equipment to monitor environmental conditions and attempt to document anything that couldn't be immediately explained by the building itself. Throughout the night, we remained focused on elimination — ruling out drafts, structural sounds, temperature differentials, and anything else the mansion might produce on its own after more than a century of standing. That process takes patience, and it takes honesty. Not every sound is a footstep. Not every cold spot is a presence. But you have to put in the hours to know the difference.
What I can tell you is that the 1890 House is a genuinely compelling location to investigate. There were moments during the night that gave us pause — instances where we documented things that we couldn't immediately attribute to the building's natural behavior. Whether those moments represent something truly unexplained or simply something we haven't fully explained yet is an important distinction, and it's one I take seriously. I never want to hand someone a paranormal conclusion when a rational one might still be out there waiting to be found. What I will say is that this location earned our attention, and the evidence we captured deserves a careful look.
The 1890 House Museum is a stunning piece of Gilded Age history, and whether you believe in the paranormal or not, it is absolutely worth exploring. As for our investigation — there are things we documented that night that I'm still thinking about, and in this work, that means something. My verdict: inconclusive, but compelling enough that I wouldn't close the book on this one.